Do you prefer...

Yes

Fantasy, until they ruin it and recast

Pike'a looks natural. Gerald looks like he bleaches.

I seen no overlap

Ooh a daddy duel!!

I'm not into men so maybe my opinion doesn't count here, going by visual appeal, I'd take Geralt over Pike any day. OTOH Pike is definitely who I'd want helping me out of a jam.

I mean Pike does cook.

Hmm. The anti-racist who canonically died fighting against a pogrom, or the ally that literally played chicken with his own life (without blinking) to try to undo systemic damage? Tough call.

Dante from Devil May Cry is fantasy so fantasy wins.