Trump’s Call to Annex Canada as a State Should Have Invoked the 25th Amendment

Jesus Christ that comes across as even worse than Putin deciding he needed to annex Ukraine. How is it that in a world of too many bad guys, we’re turning into the worse guy?

Not sure how 25th would help. vance literally was the one that called for ignoring judges and calling for their impeachment.

He should have been banned from running long ago when he incited an insurrection trying to stay in power.

A lot of things he's done should have invoked the 25th ammendment

In his deal with Putin, Trump is closing the investigations into child trafficking and kidnapping of Ukrainian children, and closing down war crimes committed by Russian military.

I agree, Trump advocating for invading Canada and Greenland is enough for the 25th Amendment and on moral grounds I hold him accountable for absolving Putin and Russia of war crimes.

That's the problem, the republican party captured the levers of power and now get to police themselves. This is what happens when you get a Republican clean sweep.

25th Amendment needs to start with the Vice President, so we know that's not going to happen:

Section 4

Whenever the Vice President and a majority of either the principal officers of the executive departments or of such other body as Congress may by law provide, transmit to the President pro tempore of the Senate and the Speaker of the House of Representatives their written declaration that the President is unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office, the Vice President shall immediately assume the powers and duties of the office as Acting President.

Thereafter, when the President transmits to the President pro tempore of the Senate and the Speaker of the House of Representatives his written declaration that no inability exists, he shall resume the powers and duties of his office unless the Vice President and a majority of either the principal officers of the executive department or of such other body as Congress may by law provide, transmit within four days to the President pro tempore of the Senate and the Speaker of the House of Representatives their written declaration that the President is unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office. Thereupon Congress shall decide the issue, assembling within forty-eight hours for that purpose if not in session. If the Congress, within twenty-one days after receipt of the latter written declaration, or, if Congress is not in session, within twenty-one days after Congress is required to assemble, determines by two-thirds vote of both Houses that the President is unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office, the Vice President shall continue to discharge the same as Acting President; otherwise, the President shall resume the powers and duties of his office.

Trump’s Call to Annex Canada as a State Should Have Invoked the 25th Amendment

The president was clearly irrational. Instead, there was Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick seconding the motion.

By Charles P. PiercePublished: Mar 17, 2025 5:29 PM EDT bookmarksSave Article president trump signs executive orders in the oval office

Chip Somodevilla//Getty Images

What has become plain this week is that the entire administration has committed itself to the president’s pipe dream of annexing Canada as the 51st state. It wasn’t just the president’s bizarre appearance with Mark Rutte, the NATO secretary general, in which the president took a short stroll around the Izonkosphere.

        “Canada only works as a state. … This would be the most incredible country
    visually. If you look at a map, they drew an artificial line right through
    it, between Canada and the U.S., just a straight artificial line. Somebody
    did it a long time ago, many, many decades ago, and makes no sense.”


  

It is necessary at this point to mention that the so-called “artificial line” is usually referred to as a “border.” The president seems to grasp the concept when referring to the “artificial line” separating the United States and Mexico. Strange, that. The president went on.

        “It’s so perfect as a great and cherished state. I love [O, Canada]. I
    think it’s great. Keep it, but it will be for the state, one of our
    greatest states, maybe our greatest state.”


  

Wonderful. He’s going to let them keep their national anthem, one of the world’s most stirring, but only as a state song, like “On the Banks of the Wabash,” “Georgia on My Mind,” or “On, Wisconsin.” I suppose he’ll let them keep their hockey teams, too.

The whole episode should have brought about an instantaneous Cabinet meeting at which the 25th Amendment was invoked. The president was clearly irrational. Instead, there was Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick seconding the motion. From the Hill:

        “The best way, the president has said it, the best way to actually merge
    the economies of Canada and the United States is for Canada to become our
    51st state. If they want to merge it, that’s how you make it the 51st
    state,” Lutnick said on Fox Business Network’s Varney & Co.


  

It really is a cult, you know.

On the Bluesky app, journalist and author Garrett Epps shrewdly pointed out that in Fletcher Knebel’s Night of Camp David, one of the first manifestations of President Mark Hollenbach’s mental illness was his secret desire to merge the United States and Canada—as well as all of Scandanavia—into a single entity called “Aspen.” In fact, the book was reissued during the first Trump administration, and it was referenced on TV by both Rachel Maddow and Bob Woodward. Now, though, with the president’s grand design seeming to parallel the grandiose foreign-policy proposal of the fictional President Hollenbach, the book has taken on an even greater salience.

(By the way, the hero of the book is a young, ambitious first-term senator named James McVeagh with whom the crazy president shares his notions in the aforementioned night at Camp David. Maybe you can see J. Divan Vance in that role, but I can’t.)

In the novel, the crazy president sounds almost rational in explaining the irrational.

        “Canada is the wealthiest nation on earth.” Hollenbach’s words raced after
    each other. …“The mineral riches under her soil are incredible in their
    immensity. Even with modern demands, they are well-nigh inexhaustible.
    Believe me, Jim, Canada will be the seat of power in the next century and,
    properly exploited and conserved, her riches can go for a thousand years.
    ...

    .. But the merger of know-how, power, and character, the United States,
    Canada, and Scandinavia, the new nation under one parliament and one
    president could keep the peace for centuries. The president of the union
    should be the man who dreamed the dreams of giants. ...

    … “I only exclude Europe at the start,” said Hollenbach, and his face
    quickly lighted again. “Right now, Europe has nothing to give us. But once
    we have built the fortress of Aspen, I predict the nations of Europe will
    pound at the door to get in. And, if they don’t, we’ll have the power to
    force them into the new nation. … There are other kinds of pressure, trade
    duties and barriers, financial measures, economic sanctions, if you will.
    But, never fear, Jim. England, France, Germany, and the Low Countries, too,
    can be brought to heel.


  

When Knebel wrote his classic Seven Days in May, about an attempted military junta in Washington, he was drawing on inside knowledge about the turmoil in the Kennedy administration between the president, the Joint Chiefs, and the intelligence community—turmoil that would do a lot to feed suspicions after the president’s murder in 1963. JFK was a big fan of the book, so much that he allowed director John Frankenheimer to photograph the White House so he could make the sets for his film adaptation.

In the case of Night of Camp David, Knebel was able to draw on American attempts to absorb Canada that dated back to the founding of the nation. In fact, Article XI of the original Articles of Confederation read as follows:

        Canada acceding to this confederation, and joining in the measures of the
    United States, shall be admitted into, and entitled to all the advantages
    of this Union.


  

The American Revolution helped the new country break off those parts of British North America in and around the Great Lakes. We tried to seize the entire country in the War of 1812, but we failed, and we got Washington burned in the bargain. Through the years up to the American Civil War, there were annexation groups on both sides of the border.

In 1860, Secretary of State William Seward came close to annexing the territory from Washington state all the way up to Alaska, which at the time was owned by Russia. For a while, it looked like Great Britain might actually swing for the deal. But,when Seward bought Alaska in 1868, the people in the region began to feel uncomfortable with the U.S. closing in from both the north and south, so popular opinion shifted. Then, of course, there were the Fenians.

The Fenian Brotherhood was a product of one of the periodic risings in Ireland against British rule. It was the American wing of what was called in Ireland the Irish Republican Brotherhood. The American Fenians were a substantial force. They had money—upwards of $500,000—and weapons and an army made up of veterans of the American Civil War. (They were led by John O’Mahony, who’d fought with the 69th New York, part of the famed Irish Brigade.) After the war, the Fenians launched a series of raids into Canada. They came in two bursts—one in 1866 and another in 1870–71. They occurred all over Canada, from Manitoba to the Maritimes. None of them succeeded, and one of them, a raid around the Minnesota–Manitoba border, never even made it into Canada. The only real result was to strengthen Canadian nationalism; the raids were pivotal in the eventual development of the Canadian confederation in 1867, an arrangement that the current U.S. president believes would make a helluva 51st state. In the debate over forming the confederation, Sir John MacDonald said:

        If we do not take advantage of the time, if we show ourselves unequal to
    the occasion, it may never return, and we shall hereafter bitterly and
    unavailingly regret having failed to embrace the happy opportunity now
    offered of founding a great nation under the fostering care of Great
    Britain, and our Sovereign Lady, Queen Victoria.


  

One of MacDonald’s primary concerns while forming the confederation was American meddling, especially in the rebellious western parts of Canada. He wrote to his minister of finance:

        I cannot understand the desire of the Colonial Office, or of the Company,
    to saddle the responsibility of the government on Canada just now. It would
    so completely throw the game into the hands of the insurgents and the
    Yankee wirepullers, who are to some extent influencing and directing the
    movement from St. Paul that we cannot foresee the consequences.


  

You always have to watch out for those Yankee wirepullers. Can’t trust them worth a damn.

What does it say?

Any threat to Canada is a threat to the whole commonwealth!

i'm going to take a counter argument here. the united states should annex canada and buy greenland.

why?

because the population of canada is more than california.

because there are 48 democratic senators.

because canada and denmark are both more left leaning than california is.

see where i'm going here? canada and greenland gives dems enough people to force through their agenda through the house and senate. and with enough backlash there's probably going to be a lot of gop senators who aren't going to be senators in 2026, probably enough to hit 69 which would be the minimum to remove trump from office. probably enough to impeach that little lickspittle vance too. and then enough votes for a democratic president (since the house would be run by democrats, 3rd in succession is the speaker of the house) to sign bills giving canada it's "independance" and return greenland to denmark.

if trump wants it that badly, then lets give it to him.