Skip Navigation
53 comments
  • To some extent we can also blame TYT's inward collapse and rightwing pivot. They were the clearing house of all things resistance and progressive. Their rightwing/ MAGA pivot has to be one of the greatest betrayals in all media. To quote Mondale Robinson: "They took too damn much from the ethos!!"

    Its not Meidas Touch, whom were never themselves progressives or even contending to be anything other than center right neoliberals and neoconservatives, its not their fault there is no media space to support progressive policies/ progressive news reporting.

    The Majority Report (Sam Seder/ Emma) is great, but its not a "pure news" show in the way that TYT or Meidas Touch is. Its too wonky, too 'pure politics' in the traditional sense of political reporting. Its a politics show for people are deep into it. TYT was a daily show for people to take in, after the events of the day, but they've jumped the shark.

    Because of this there is a void, and despite them being maybe not the right size/ shape, people are starving for honest reporting, or anything that seems to be representing it.

    I'd love to see the whole "grab bag" of leftist political shows bundle up into one show, and produce an evening news show. Its too much "political hot takes" and not enough "news of the day". Of course, make your political hot-takes, but mostly, just tell me what happened.

  • As cringe as liberals are, I don't know if it's politically savvy for a progressive writer to do a long format hitpiece on an alternative to Joe Rogan and other much worse podcasts. Clickbait in general is an accepted necessary evil on YouTube and while Meidas is potent example of how bad it looks for an outsider looking in, I don't think that should have been the crux of the article.

    The author's criticism of Palestine coverage is valid, but making that the entire personality of the left does risk chasing away people who are already heavily biased against it from Fox, for example. It's not great to avoid it completely, but from the sound of it, they haven't entirely removed it from their coverage. Also, they criticize the Trump focus, but that is probably what political refugees from the right are thinking when they search for new shores.

    I personally prefer Humanist Report, Vaush, and Hasan's politics, but if Meidas is more successful, it's easier to pull liberals than fascists to the left.

53 comments