cross posting my own post here. Just realized there's two googlepixel communities. Just an FYI. Peak Design did acknowledge my email them, but no updates from them.
Ya my PD case for the P7P has charged on anything I've put it on so far. I am not sure where the problem lies with the P8P setup but the stand I have now is no longer working. :(
Thanks that's good to know! It sucks but they protect themselves with the "Note that compatibility with all 3rd party chargers (even Qi certified chargers) is not guaranteed" fine-print. However depending on where you live you should still be able to return it I think.
The charger I've owned for a little while, and it's probably long past the return period.
The case I'll keep since I have 3 PD chargers in our cars and one with the clip mount on my motorcycle that I use quite a bit.
I played Around with trying different positions tonight and that charger does not like the PD case :( the phone will charge on the buds pad laying flat with the PD case on.
It also charges with my wife's magsafe charger. So overall it seems to just be the on wireless charger, unfortunately it's one I used semi often.