Skip Navigation
34 comments
  • Back in the day, I was running a game with friends. They both decided to play precocious kids, with a lot of power (magical and family) but in need of extra guidance.

    So, they had a DMPC that was from Maine, and had the stereotypical accent like Fred Gwynne had in Pet Sematary. So he's talking about systems of magic, gods and spirits in that Mainer drawl.

    We ended up playing pretty much every night for a month or two, and with me doing the accent so much, I had trouble shaking the accent irl.

    It was a great fucking campaign tbh. We had a shit ton of fun just rampaging around and wrecking shit with their pair of grossly wealthy and grossly over powered siblings and their "uncle". The two kids were British, so those cheesy accents were in play, and they were from a posh witch family, which makes this post extra funny for me.

  • clone wars and farscape teach us that oceanic (oceaniac?) accents come from space so it's probably a character option in one of the spelljammer books

  • I know someone who moved to the USA recently and learned English as a second language as an air and I had to explain this to them when they started playing Baldur's Gate 3.

    Western Fantasy is nearly entirely based on Dark Age and Medieval Europe, and for English speakers (in particular English speaking Americans) that usually means it's based on England/UK in particular because it's the country that speaks English.

    So, a huge majority of fantasy characters have an English accent because it's the accent associated with the only place in the world that spoke English during the vague target time fantasy is set in or based on.

    Of course English sounded very different at that time in England, but the tie between them is so strong and has continued for so long it's now the tradition/expectation.

    Like, as an exercise, consider if you were to watch a classical Western-fantasy-type show like Game of Thrones or a Lord of the Rings series. If everyone had modern American accents (general, Southern, etc) wouldn't you immediately notice and find it odd and out of place?

    PS: the person in question was really quite great at English but had to install a mod to add subtitles in their native language because they struggled greatly with non-American accents.

34 comments