Programmer Humor @programming.dev onlinepersona @programming.dev 4 mo. ago

"No way to prevent this" say users of only language where this regularly happens - 07/01/2024

xeiaso.net "No way to prevent this" say users of only language where this regularly happens

Xe Iaso's personal website.

A shitpost about languages that generate CVEs

20 comments

Also, I like how this problem had a really simple solution all along

There really isn't anything we can do to prevent memory safety vulnerabilities from happening if the programmer doesn't want to write their code in a robust manner.

Yeah, totally, it's all those faulty programmers fault. They should've written good programmes instead of the bad ones, but they just refuse to listen
- Right, those devs with 20+ years C experience don't know shit about the language and are just lazy. They don't want to catch up with the times and write safe C. It's me, the dude with 5 years of university experience who will set it straight. Look at my hello world program, not a single line of vulnerable code.
  
  Anti Commercial-AI license
  
  This is not completely wrong, though
  
  It has nothing to do with knowing the language and everything to do with what's outside of the language. C hasn't resembled CPUs for decades and can't be reasonably retrofitted for safety.
- Well yeah, 100% of programming errors are programmers fault.
lol this same post got flagged and taken down from HN
- Well, lemmy is a place for much more cultured audience. We can appreciate a good shitpost (that does also hold some water).
The "C is bad trope" is getting way too old. I'm surprised the author didn't plug Rust.

the only programming language in the world where these vulnerabilities regularly happen

Maybe because it's one of the most widely used languages in the world...
- The trope will be "old" once the mainstream view is no longer that C-style memory management is "good enough".
  
  That said, this particular vulnerability was primarily due to how signals work, which I understand to be kind of unavoidably terrible in any language.
  
  A better language wouldn't have any need to use POSIX signals in this way.
- Well, one of the most widely used that allows to do low-level stuff. The most widely used one is by far JavaScript but good luck making an OS or a device driver with it
  
  I'm sure there are projects covering those areas written in JavaScript.
... the only language where 90% of the world's memory safety vulnerabilities have occurred in the last 50 years

Yeah... That's a shit post alright.

I'm not a C developer myself, but that's just a low blow. Also, uncited ;).
- This is an overstatement, definitely. C is one of the few (mainstream) languages where memory safety vulnerabilities are even possible. So if you batch C and C++ together, they probably cover more than 90% of all the memory unsafe cove written in last 50 years, which is a strong implication that they will contribute to 90% of memory vulnerabilities.
  
  All that said, memory vulnerabilities are about 65% of all high implact vulnerabilities on Chromium project^1 and about 70% of vulnerabilities at Microsoft ^2.
  
  So we'd only fix 70% of vulnerabilities by switching to rust? Not enough! Better keep writing C/C++!
- Yeah the only way it would be that high is if it lumps C and C++ together. But at that point it may be an underestimate.

You've viewed 20 comments.