Capital gains tax 'last thing the Canadian economy needs,' say business groups
Capital gains tax 'last thing the Canadian economy needs,' say business groups
"Such measures would deter investment at a time when we are striving to boost competitiveness and innovation within the industry and across the economy."
Which economy? The lived economy of the general public or the artificial economy of finance?
Wouldn't both see a beneficial uptick from capital injection?
Capital isn't injected, it's hoarded.
The rich are already doing fine. They're doing better than they have since 1920. As a class, they have so much money that they're able to do stock buybacks because investing it doesn't give moneygasm-style returns. We're nearing the point where they can Scrooge McDuck-style swimming pools full of cash.
The problem with the current economy is very much not that the wealthy don't have enough free capital. Quite the opposite, really.
The problem is that they have so much free capital because they're addicted to non-productive methods growing their wealth.
I have no idea, but I'd like the powers that be to recognize that there are two economies and to prioritize the lived economy.
I first became aware of the difference when "the economy" was starting to boom in the 1980s even as we were busy returning to breadlines under the name of food banks.
I'm not sure we even need the finance economy. A pure stock market is one thing, but by the time you get to rents over profit on actual production, the financialization of housing, derivatives of derivatives and all the other distancing from actual production, it's just shell games with no benefit to society.
Sure, but which business injects capital in te first?
Your comment seems reasonable until you actually question the details:
How would forgoing a capital gains tax benefit the working public? Any answer you give will basically be "trickle down" economics, which has been proven to not work. Giant corporations and obscenely wealthy individuals hoard capital like a greedy dragon, they certainly don't inject it!
EDIT: Of course they couldn't answer that one simple question...
The wailing of hedge fund managers and the minions of the super rich is what lets us know the government is doing the right thing.
LOL at billionaires crying about being taxed.
More than just billionaires. Anyone who invests. But that’s disproportionately richer people, so it’s good. My complaint is that the tax isn’t raised enough.
Rich people's yacht money says what?
It's an interesting thing that has happened to businesses lately, where making money isn't good enough, they have to be making outrageous amounts or it's not worth the effort. They'd rather close up shop than be forced to endure only modest profit
Such measures would deter investment at a time when we are striving to boost competitiveness and innovation within the industry and across the economy
competitiveness
Innovation like unnecessary return to office and less than inflation raises!
Don't forgot about the pizza or one single box of slightly stale Tims donuts for an entire office. We're a family here and our culture is important!!!
Innovation like a new coat of paint over chat-gpt and prompt "engineer". Real value created here.
"Sure would be a shame if you taxed us and something happened to your economy..."
Ah, someone else who remembers the way the titans of industry and finance ratfucked the Rae government.
Oh, we need to boost competitiveness, do we?
How about we stop the rich from investing in non-productive asset classes like real estate, which seems to be the reason every economist says we're stuck in a quagmire; because capital is being sucked up by real estate and financialization instead of investment into, well, anything else?
We could do that by...taxing the fuck out of capital gains?
No. Capital must go towards rent seeking. It's only logical to invest in things that make money for free.
This is labour's fault. If only we'd work harder and demand less pay (while not ever reducing spending), the economy would be great!
(/s, just in case)
How does principal residence work when you are moving and the related buying and selling?
No capital gains on principal residence. It would only come up on things like rental properties, cabins, or any other second property.
There’s also things like of a person has RRSP room and ends up in the edge case where this comes up just once or a few times in their life, they can use that to hold off the income tax until they can claim it at a lower tax bracket. If one isn’t put over by a single sale, (say selling multiple rental properties at retirement) they could spread those sales over multiple years to maximize that first $250k rate.
Funny how there is no alternative method of reducing or reversing the growing wealth disparity presented. The class of people who have done better than not only every other Canadian but virtually everyone else on Earth since the last world war that they ALSO profited from is telling us it is unfair to them while a growing number of people cannot eat and house themselves any longer. The very reason people cannot afford to survive is because the top is taking a larger portion of our productivity every single year.