Food. They already have the gift of eating a f#% expensive food and ruling my house because they are spoiled. I think they are the 1% of cats. They don't get sesonal gifts.
lol, tha's a joke. They get gifts every week when I go to the pet store to buy food
A. Squeaky Rudolph, a smart cat toy that does three different things, catnip, a new bed, a rope mouse, a rabbit fur mouse, treats, and the box it came in.
Boxes serve him well. My cat gets very bored of a toy after using it maybe once or twice, so buying toys is basically a waste. Just cut some string, or tinfoil ball, etc, and it'll make him very happy.
I gave my neighbor kitty a carrot. The, uh, carrot thief was not amused. Halloween he got himself a mando armor set (EVA foam. I had to catsit him the night I also was helping the niece and nephew with their costumes. We were doing mandalorian suits, so, they decided he needed one too.)