Skip Navigation
47 comments

  • Everybody is on the right track that Torx or Robertson are by far the best driver heads, but y'all are not even looking at the threads and shanks. Lots to unpack here. If you are allowed an angle grinder or die grinder, then going longer might be better. Hardwoods don't like fine-pitched threads at all, and while sheet metal screws can work in a lot of wood products it's not ideal. Then, can you countersink, or are you going to be stuck the rest of your life with screw heads standing proud of the workpiece?

    This is some serious shit, you guys, and should not be reduced to "Robertson 4 LYF!" We need a couple of committees and some use-case analyses and some brainstorming on workarounds with our inevitable compromise pick. It's gonna be exhausting!!!!!!!

    • <3 is named that for a reason. The thread pitch is pretty versatile, it's not too long, it's countersunk, and it's Robertson.

    • 👆 Standards exist for a reason.

    • Computer - Generate the ultimate treatise comparing types of screws. include details about the head, drive, length, pitch, material, and any other details that could possibly be relevant.

      The Ultimate Treatise on Screws: A Comparative Analysis

      Introduction

      Screws are one of the most fundamental fasteners in modern engineering and construction. Their variety allows for extensive application across multiple industries, from woodworking to aerospace. Understanding the types of screws is essential for selecting the right one for a particular application. This treatise will delve into various types of screws based on head type, drive type, length, pitch, material composition, coatings, and specific applications.

      1. Screw Classification

      1.1 Head Types

      The head of a screw is crucial because it determines how the screw will interface with tools and the material into which it is driven. The main types of screw heads include:

      • Flat Head: Designed to sit flush with the material. Commonly used in woodworking and cabinetry.
      • Pan Head: Slightly rounded head that provides a larger bearing surface. Ideal for applications where a bit of protrusion is acceptable.
      • Round Head: A fully rounded head that projects above the surface. Used primarily in decorative applications.
      • Hex Head: Features a hexagonal shape for wrenching. Common in heavy machinery and structural applications.
      • Oval Head: A cross between flat and round heads with a polished appearance; used primarily in projects where aesthetics are a concern.
      • Truss Head: A low-profile but wide head, often used in applications that require a significant surface area without a large vertical profile.

      1.2 Drive Types

      The drive type of a screw denotes the form of the recess on the head that is meant to engage with a driving tool. Common drive types include:

      • Slotted: A single horizontal slot. Easy to manufacture but less effective at preventing cam-out.
      • Phillips: A cross shape that allows for more torque and less likelihood of slippage. Widely used in various applications.
      • Pozidriv: Similar to Phillips but with additional ribs for improved torque and lesser risk of stripping.
      • Torx (Star): A six-point star shape that provides high torque and reduced cam-out, widely used in automotive and electronic assemblies.
      • Square (Robertson): A square recess that allows for strong engagement with tools, often used in woodworking.

      1.3 Length

      The length of a screw varies considerably and is generally measured from the underside of the head to the tip of the screw. Length selection is vital for achieving secure fastening without compromising structural integrity. Common lengths range from 1/2 inch to 10 inches or more, depending on the application.

      1.4 Pitch

      Pitch refers to the distance between threads, typically measured in threads per inch (TPI) for imperial screws or in millimeters for metric screws. Different pitch sizes affect the screw's grip and pull-out strength:

      • Coarse Pitch (Low TPI): Provides better grip in soft materials and is suitable for quick assembly.
      • Fine Pitch (High TPI): Offers greater holding power in harder materials but requires more torque to drive.

      1.5 Material Composition

      Screws can be made from various materials, each with unique properties:

      • Steel: The most common material, often galvanized or heat-treated for increased strength and corrosion resistance.
      • Stainless Steel: Offers excellent corrosion resistance, making it ideal for marine and outdoor applications.
      • Copper: Known for antimicrobial properties, often used in electrical applications and plumbing.
      • Aluminum: Lightweight and resistant to corrosion but with lower tensile strength.
      • Plastic: Used where non-conductivity or corrosion resistance is critical, such as in electronic assemblies.

      1.6 Coatings and Finishes

      Coatings can significantly enhance screw performance:

      • Zinc Plating: Offers limited corrosion resistance; suitable for indoor applications.
      • Galvanization: A thicker zinc coating for enhanced outdoor corrosion resistance.
      • Black Oxide: Provides a mild corrosion resistance and a sleek appearance; commonly used in automotive parts.
      • PTFE or Nylon Coating: Reduces friction and can dampen noise. Used in concealed applications.

      2. Specialty Screws

      2.1 Wood Screws

      • Designed specifically for woodworking with shallow threads for ease of driving and minimal splitting.

      2.2 Machine Screws

      • Thinner and with uniform diameter, often used with nuts or tapped holes.

      2.3 Self-Tapping Screws

      • Create their own thread as they are driven into materials, eliminating pre-drilling. Often used in metal and plastic.

      2.4 Lag Screws

      • Heavy-duty screws with a square or hex head, used for fastening heavy timbers or metal to wood.

      2.5 Sheet Metal Screws

      • Specifically designed for piercing metal sheets, featuring sharp threads and sometimes a self-drilling tip.

      3. Applications

      3.1 Construction

      In this setting, screws are used in framing, flooring, and roofing. The type of head and drive is often chosen based on the required complexity of the task and the necessary torque.

      3.2 Electronics

      Tiny screws hold components together and are mostly made from non-magnetic materials or those with anti-corrosive coatings.

      3.3 Aerospace

      Screws must be lightweight yet strong, often made from specialized alloys or composites.

      3.4 Automotive

      With high demands for safety and performance, the anti-corrosion properties of screws are crucial.

      Conclusion

      The world of screws is vast, encompassing a multitude of varieties tailored for specific tasks. Understanding the characteristics of screws—including head types, drive types, length, pitch, materials, and coatings—allows for informed selection and application. Whether for a simple DIY project or complex industrial applications, selecting the right screw ensures structural integrity, durability, and aesthetic appeal. As industries continuously evolve, so too will the innovations surrounding screws and fastening technologies.

      • Computer - Rewrite this but you are extremely opinionated about your favorite screw type. Use an angry, combative tone, and insult the reader.

        The Ultimate Treatise on Screws: My No-Nonsense Opinion

        Introduction

        Let’s get one thing straight: if you don’t understand the importance of screws, then what are you even doing? You’re probably struggling with basic tasks and getting your projects all wrong. Well, buckle up, because I’m about to lay down the law on screws, and you’d better be paying attention. In this rant, I’ll tear apart the types of screws, and I’ll tell you unequivocally which one reigns supreme. Spoiler alert: if you think anything other than my favorite screw type is the best, you’re dead wrong.

        1. Screw Classification

        1.1 Head Types

        Let’s talk head types. If you think a flat head is the pinnacle of screw design, you need to rethink your entire life. Flat heads look like a mistake. The dumbest screw imaginable, designed to sit flush with the surface. Wake up! The best option is clearly the Hex Head! It’s got everything you need—torque, grip, and the ability to withstand real pressure. If you’re not using hex heads in your projects, you’re the reason DIY stores have so many return customers.

        1.2 Drive Types

        Now onto drive types. If you’re still using a slotted screw, stop right there. It’s 2023, and slotted screws are the fastener equivalent of dial-up internet. Phillips screws? Pathetic! They’re better than slotted, sure, but they still slip and strip like no one's business. The only way to go is with Torx screws! That six-point star design screams efficiency and strength. If you’re not on board with Torx, then allow me to be blunt: you deserve to struggle with inept screws.

        1.3 Length

        Length matters, alright? But for crying out loud, how hard is it to figure out the correct length for your needs? If you pick a screw that’s too short, you’ve doomed yourself to weak joints. Pick one that’s too long, and you’ve just ruined whatever you’re working on. Take the time to measure! Length is crucial. But if we’re being honest, a solid average length of around 2 to 3 inches is what you should standardize on. Anything less is admitting defeat.

        1.4 Pitch

        Oh, and pitch? You think coarse pitch screws work in everything? Guess what? They don’t! If you want reliability, go for a fine pitch. Coarse pitch is just an excuse for laziness: it grips poorly and moves all over the place. If you’re serious about your project, fine pitch is the way to go, period!

        1.5 Material Composition

        Let’s address materials, shall we? If you’re still using regular steel screws without any corrosion protection, congratulations! You’ve unlocked the “Rusty Screw” achievement. Stainless steel is the only way to ensure durability and longevity, but don’t get all smug thinking that’s enough. You better be checking for quality. Aluminum? Get real, that’s only good for lightweight junk.

        1.6 Coatings and Finishes

        Coatings? If you think just any coating is good enough, you’re living in a delusion! Go for galvanization if you want to avoid the rust monster. Black oxide? Sure, if you want to look cool but still have vulnerabilities. But let's not even talk about plastic screws unless you enjoy living on the wild side of mediocrity. You're way better off with a screw that has purpose—like a stainless steel screw coated for maximum resistance.

        2. Specialty Screws

        2.1 Wood Screws

        If you’re still using those cheap wood screws that make your joints squeal like a banshee, save yourself the embarrassment and invest in something worth your time. Wood screws are your friends if you put them in a spot where they won't destructively split your precious wood.

        2.2 Machine Screws

        Machine screws? Thin, uniform, and destined for fastening? Great if you’re trying to hold two pieces of metal together without ambition. Otherwise, don't even think about it.

        2.3 Self-Tapping Screws

        Let’s talk self-tapping screws. If you think you can avoid pre-drilling, more power to your overly confident self! But guess what? If you mess it up, you’ll wish you’d done it the right way.

        2.4 Lag Screws

        Lag screws are for heavy-duty applications, and if you’re not using them when warranted, you’re insulting your work! Don’t even show your face at any hardware store unless you understand when and why to use lag screws—you’re just embarrassing everyone around you.

        2.5 Sheet Metal Screws

        If you’re working with metal but think you can get away with regular screws, you’re dead wrong. Sheet metal screws have the muscle you need to bite through solid materials. Without them, you’re better off tossing your project in the trash.

        3. Applications

        3.1 Construction

        In construction, the best screw is the one that handles stress without snapping like a twig. Hex heads and Torx screws should be your go-to. If you don’t agree, go ahead and continue to face your carpentry disasters!

        3.2 Electronics

        If you can't figure out which screws to use in electronics, you might as well quit right now. Use the screws made for the job, not some random junk from the bottom of your toolbox.

        3.3 Aerospace

        Aerospace applications demand strength, precision, and the utmost quality. If you’re even considering cheap screws for this field, you should take a long, hard look in the mirror and admit that you have no business delving into anything advanced.

        3.4 Automotive

        And let’s not forget about automobiles! If you put anything less than top-quality screws in them, you’re asking for catastrophic failures. Your life or someone else’s could hinge on the integrity of those fasteners, you fool!

        Conclusion

        To sum it up: if you don’t understand screws after reading this, then you’re hopeless. The only correct screw is the Torx screw—strong, resilient, and reliable. If you find yourself arguing otherwise, you’re simply wrong, and you can take that ignorance elsewhere. It’s time to step up your game and recognize that screws are more than just metal; they are the backbone of secure, reliable construction! Do yourself a favor: educate yourself and start using the right screws, or keep failing and sink back into your mediocre existence. Your choice!

47 comments