Linux 101 stuff. Questions are encouraged, noobs are welcome! @lemmy.world Telorand @reddthat.com 5 mo. ago

[Solved] How can I make a custom .service run as root?

I have a VPN daemon that needs to run before the client will work. Normally, this would have been set up automatically by its install script, but the system is immutable.

I've created the systemd service via sysyemctl edit --force --full daemon.service with the following parameters:

[Unit] 
Description=Blah
After=network-online.target

[Service]
User=root
Group=root
ExecStart=/usr/bin/env /path/to/daemon

[Install]
WantedBy=multi-user.target

I've verified that the daemon is actually executable, and it runs fine when I manually call it via sudo daemon. When I try to run it with sudo systemctl enable --now daemon.service, it exits with error code 126.

What am I missing?

Edit: typo

Edit 2: Added script modifications. Daemon appears to be some kind of pre-compiled binary.

Solution: ExecStart wanted /usr/bin/env to launch the binary. The service file above has been edited to reflect the correct solution. See this post for further discussion.

10 comments

Typically you instruct systemd to run a service as a specific user/group with a User= and Group= directive in the [Service] section of the unit file.

The error code indicates the command is found but is not executable.

Is this service running under your user context? Generally when I am building a system service I put it under /etc/systemd/system and it runs as root without issues unless I specify.
- The service is in that folder, but it's not automatically assuming to run as root. Maybe it's an SELinux thing, since this is on Bazzite...?
  
  Either way, I tried adding
  
  [Service] User=root Group=root ExecStart=...
  
  And it's still throwing that 126. It's definitely executable, but maybe it's not a bash script, though I dunno what else you'd use to run it. To manually start it, you just type sudo /path/to/daemon (no file extension).
  
  Edit: definitely not a bash script. Kate can't read it. It looks like it's some kind of pre-compiled binary.
  
  Does the service include execute permission for the root user or group? Unsure if root user or group can be blocked from permissions or not, but do you have chmod +x and the service is owned by root and/or the x is in the “everyone” place?
Does it say in your service file Wanted By or WantedBy?
- The latter. Autocorrect got that one.
Why use /bin/bash in your ExecStart directive? You can just specify the path to your daemon.

/bin/bash expects a script, not a binary, which your daemon most probably is…
- Nope, leaving off the initial env call, in this corrected case, gives a 203/EXEC error.
  
  It would have been easy if I could just call the binary, but alas. Dunno why, but there it is.
  
  ETA: this is on Bazzite, so maybe systemctl behaves slightly differently...?
  
  Additional question: when starting the daemon from the cli, does it terminate?

You've viewed 10 comments.