The animations showing the transformation of a page into a blah-SEO clone really sold the article for me. Really reminds me of how shitty the "modern" web is nowadays. I also think it's time I signed up for Kagi.
Google imperfected the web. As in made it unsafer, privacy is a joke. The "old" internet was good, but it couldnt get monetized.
Google showed us all that advertisments arent your friend, rather they are harmfull, just because of google there are so many users that use especially for youtube or google adblockers, so that they dont have to see "Milfs in your area" on a "Childrens Platform" ( youtube ).
If you search for something for example "docker postgresql" first results are ads ( malicious spam, virus, trojaner ) then there comes like 50 blog posts about postgresql and sometimes with docker in the title. After scrolling to page 2 there it is after another 2-3 ads there is your wanted page... oh wait no its just a dynamic page that insert {search query} into the title and has some icon detection. After that you go to another search engine DuckDuckGo... first result it is your wanted page. Or even use a open source search engine collector like SearXNG that asks multiple search engines for a result.
And almost everything you're talking about is prior to GPT generated content filling the internet. At least when you are reading a blog, it was written by a human being who put care into their work, and if they're wrong, it's probably a typo.
We badly need a search engine that's got human-generated content on the other side, and if anybody is writing SEO tutorials, all they should be able to say is "Don't be misleading with your content"
The thing that made Reddit valuable was that it was a bastion of user-generated content. To a great extent, it still is... Unless you happen to be avoiding their website for ethical reasons, which is understandable.
That's also why they're trying to hold on to it by any means necessary; they know that the software itself isn't any good without the data that has been generated using it.
I hope Lemmy search functionality gets better. Right now, it's pretty slow from an instance, and I haven't ever seen its stuff pop up in a conventional search engine.
I started using Kagi yesterday! It was a huge shock to get great results on a search at the top. Plus having those horrible spammy "Best VPNs of 2023 on bestvpns.com" all get grouped together under a heading of "Listicles" is just perfect. I'm telling co-workers about Kagi and not a single one is interested, but I'll keep using it damn it!
Sounds great; yea, I'm getting sick of the shitty SEOed the hella out results I'm getting from Google search nowadays. If I'm searching for anything that's not pure facts (which likely leads me to a wiki page anyway), it's just going to be a shitshow of bland pages as described in the linked article.