@Wooster @LtLiana There’s also the interesting examples of John M Ford’s Klingons and Diane Duane’s Romulans - both of those authors’ works became touchstones for others - until TNG sort of swept away the Klinzhai and Rihansuu

@frankPodmore @ValueSubtracted I feel about the same. The songs and singing were not memorable in the slightest and I keep watching it in 5-10 minute bits because I just don’t care about it. But a brave experiment anyway. They can’t all be winners.