Search
When exercise of rights is made conditional on use of technology, is the right violated?
cross-posted from: https://links.hackliberty.org/post/213918
I’m increasingly encountering situations where people are forced to go through various kinds of technical hoops in order to exercise their legal rights.
Five examples:
① You have a right to reserve streetside public parking in front of your house (e.g. for a week-long construction project). Historically you can go to city hall or the like, give your schedule, and pay a fee. But then they decided to put the reservation system exclusively online. Cash payers are excluded. Offline people are excluded. People who are online but do not want to share their email address with an office that uses Microsoft for their email are also excluded.
② You have a right to unemployment benefits. But the unemployment office goes online and forces you to solve a Google reCAPTCHA. Google’s reCAPTCHA often refuses to serve the puzzles to Tor users. People who are on clearnet may be unable to solve the CAPTCHA. Some people /can/ s