I'm making a guide to Pocket alternatives: getoffpocket.com
Pocket is Shutting Down: Guide to Open Source Alternatives
Still a work in progress, but even at this stage, I hope it can help you and anyone you know who has been affected by the Pocket shutdown.
Karakeep seems more active than any of these, with a larger feature set potentially: https://github.com/karakeep-app/karakeep
Which one works best to get around the cookie popups? This was always a problem before where all you would get is the popup.
Your entry for Omnivore says the link to the hosted version is broken. That's because it shut down at the end of last year.
It was a good option for read-it-later, whereas most of the of the bookmarking self-hosted apps seems more focused on saving and sorting links.
Do you know if there is any interest in resurrecting it?
I think it still exists like you can self host it. But the hosting shut down.
Was wondering why this was posted on technology, but it turns out it is not selling what I'd expect with that website name.
I want my get-off pocket >:(
Thank you to everyone who commented! I'm digesting all of what has been said and will be adjusting the guide as I can. If you're able, donations are welcome! (See link on the site)
The only reason I used Pocket was to save longer articles, ebooks, journals, etc with one click so they would sync with the free p2k (Pocket2Kindle) service and automatically end up on my Kindle. Is there anything similar?
That's exactly what I used it for, and the best alternative is Instapaper. Their free version does a bit more than p2k. They've jacked up the price of their paid option, but since I only care about the Kindle feature, I live without it.
Good question! I know Wallabag has some eReader integrations through KOReader. People on Kobo devices seem to like it especially. There may be other options too. I'll look at this some more! I'd appreciate anyone sharing details that they know too.
I set up Wallabag on my Kobo last week and really don't like it when compared with the default Pocket implementation. Having to mess about getting it set up, and having to install KOReader just to replicate a function I already had and used extensively is irritating as hell. And it's not as good either.
Fuck Mozilla. They didn't have to buy Pocket, and they didn't have to shut it down. The pricks.
Readeck also has a KOReader integration via OPDS catalogue
I always forget the Kindle has a basic web browser. In lieu of a sync service/native apps, I wonder if any of these alternatives would work decently enough in the Kindle web browser with Article Mode.
And for what it’s worth, I use this Firefox extension to send articles directly to my Kindle without Pocket/any service in the middle.
No, it shows up as a downloaded book, no browser required! Well, you have to be connected to Wi-Fi (or have the mobile version) to "Whispersync" initially, but once it's on there, you can read it offline, delete it, send it to the cloud, etc. It does open the browser if you want to archive or favorite it to your Pocket account, but you could do that when you have service again, or just not use that functionality...
Love the list, just a quick callout, these are pretty resource light services for self hosting, even $5/month seems like a stretch.
If you're already running a server, the added overhead for a bookmark manager has got to be fractional watts, especially of you're not bookmarking constantly.
If you're doing a standalone server just for this, these can more than likely be hosted on a Raspberry Pi which uses 5W under load (maybe $1/mo under heavy load), and are incredibly lean when idle (pennies/month).
I do think your post does a good job making people think about the hidden costs of self hosting, but done right self hosting energy can be greatly reduced
I would love to see one, and please tell me if I missed it in the list, that keeps bookmarks in a git repo. I don’t need the read it later aspect just the link.
If you just want to keep track of your bookmarks using git, floccus can do that.
Thanks. Def checking this out.
Thanks for this. I was already using Inoreader (with a Supporter subscription) and they made it easy to grab my Pocket content.
Now the only thing I need to figure out is what I'll do as a replacement to the Kobo + Pocket integration.
I'm really enjoying Karakeep, but I never used Pocket so I don't know how they compare.
Is it good for read-it-later functionality, for example to read from a phone without online connectivity?
Offline support is planned but not supported yet according to the website.
I was going to say that I use Hoarder and like it, but it looks like it's been renamed to Karakeep. I like the AI-powered tagging functionality.
The author had problems with a copyright claim with the name Hoarder unfortunately.
I could be missing something but I never see Karakeep when the pocket shutdown is being mentioned. I’m curious ppl don’t know or don’t like karakeep?