2mo ago

euphemism treadmill is not a get out of rule free card pt2

i do not believe these words should be abandoned!

my intent is to point out and critique society’s weaponization of words, not the words themselves.

also! this is a descriptive post, not perscriptive

what that means is just that i want ppl to be aware that this pattern has happened in the past and of course the forces behind those happenings haven’t just disappeared. i think pride in being ND and the fact that “neurodiverse” is a word that is created by its own community are powerful reasons to doubt that the word will have the same fate. perhaps i would call this a “call to awareness” post rather than a call to action.

(making this disclaimer because a couple people are violently adamant that i am just trying to make an argument saying all these words are the same and predicting the future, which, sorry you got that impression it’s not true. but now you know!)

57 comments

OP, at a certain point there has to be a word to describe what is happening. Just because someone uses it in a derogatory manner doesn't mean that you have to abandon the word or that every usage of it is derogatory.
See: gay
Alternatively, make a third meme about it on a niche Internet forum.
- It's the Euphemism Treadmill
  https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/euphemism_treadmill
  
  Funny thing is the neurodivergent aren't the ones running on that treadmill.
  It literally doesn't matter what you change the word to, that's the new word I'm calling my friend when he does something incredibly stupid.
  
  Hijacking this comment to say: I don’t even think the word should be abandoned. That’s an assumption that rugul totally made up.
  My aim in posting is to be descriptive, showing the pattern of behavior, rather than perscriptive. I’m not telling anyone what to do or say other than “hey, be aware of how this tends to happen!”
- We understand that. Tell society that. We're not exactly the march in the street crowd so when we get yelled at we go back to the corner and think of a new name.
  
  Maybe don’t go back in the corner? You need to learn to stand up for yourself otherwise you’ll just be bullied for the rest of your life.
  Not just you, anyone with this attitude.
  Oh boo fucking hoo they’re mean to you? Be even meaner.
- Just because someone uses it in a derogatory manner doesn’t mean that you have to abandon the word or that every usage of it is derogatory.
  I never said that anyone should abandon the word?!? In fact, I would far prefer reclaiming of slurs that reempowers the disabled community with their own language. But you didn’t know that because instead of asking you jumped to an entirely different topic.
  
  This is you right now.
  
  I see you went with option two lol.

If I'm not mistaken, all those other terms were imposed on people not really self described.
I think neurodivergent will survive because people can proud to be neurodivergent. It's closer to an identity than a prescriptive label.
I for one am proud to be neurodivergent.
- I think neurodivergent will survive because people can proud to be neurodivergent.
  💪💪i share your hope. having pride in your identity is a powerful thing. ❤️

More than half of those are outdated jargon words from when standard procedure to "cure" ND people (and other undesirables) was lobotomies. They were not claimed.
- Yeah, but it holds true for the later ones.

"Neurodivergent" is a bit different though. The r-word says something normative about people's mental development. It's saying that the person has been prevented from being normal; that something is wrong with them. "Special needs" indicates that someone requires different resources than what is typical. Much like IQ when it was developed, it's a way to sort people's needs on an economic basis, which isn't poorly intentioned. However, it still labels people by how we need certain things within our socioeconomic system.
Disorder classification systems like the DSM or ICD seek to normalize people, making sure we "function" in society. It measures us by a set of standards to ensure that we can live independently with our environment. It is very much defined by how society is structured; the environment of industrial capitalism. It doesn't matter how fulfilling your life is, only that you are a functional cog.
"Neurodivergence" seeks to avoid the pathology based approach. It says nothing about us having disorders. It instead focuses on us as different and divergent from the norm, but not inherently ill because of who we are. It's invariant to economic systems or cultural norms, only saying that we are different.
- Absolutely. All of the terms in the post are a bit different from one another. All came from varying origins and backgrounds and have different histories of how they came to be in my post.
  What they share is a pattern of similarities. They all are originally polite descriptive words that became demeaning.
  
  The first four terms became associated with disabilities through the medical field. The first two terms were categories on the IQ-Scale (idiot is the one that comes before imbecile in that scale, btb). The third is a shortening of a medical term conflated with another (spasticity and clonus) and the fourth is another psychological term referring to similar things as the first two.
  Those were originally meant to be clinical but have been abused by those people, they also were created from outside the community (special needs most likely too, as it is a euphemism). I am unsure about "Acoustic", that might be embracing of a meme, unless it was used as a euphemism for autism by non-autistic people.
  Neurodivergent is different, this is a term coined by a part of the community. I am not sure whether the term endonym is accurate here but it is similar in nature.

Idk. I can’t agree to the game being played here bc all they have to do is say it with that sneering condescension and then it’s a slur.
I’m gonna take a page from gay people, because I am a gay person. Remember before it was a slur attempt it meant HAPPY and we fucking TOOK it from them. We took a word thateant something GOOD and they can’t ever have it back. Fuck them.
So fuck em again. I’m not divergent. I’m … idk. People who can do what I can do are “NORMAL”, or “NATURAL”. Aww, you have problems learning about things you like and talking about them? You can’t write code or understand logic puzzles? Why can’t you keep up huh?? Why can’t you memorise things or babble for an hour on command, what’s wrong with you? Well not everyone can be NORMAL. 🤟🖕
- hell yeah. fuck that grim reaper and his game. fully support reclamation.

Idk im Autistic and I use "regarded", neurotypicals can fuck off if they feel offended
- The r-slur is targeted at intellectually disabled people. It's not something for you to reclaim. When people call non-intellectually disabled autistic people that, the insult is that they're comparing them to intellectually disabed people.
  
  And why is it an insult? Because nobody wants to be seen as intellectually disabled. No matter what new words we make up, mean people will always use them to make other people feel bad. It's not the words, it's the ideas behind them.
  
  excellent and fair analysis.
- Why "regarded"? I don't get it tbh. To me it just says that you want to call someone "retarded" but you're just too much of a coward to commit. Like, it communicates the exact same contempt for someone's cognitive abilities but also an aversion to using a proper No-No Word™ because you don't wanna transgress some sorta social taboo against them while doing so. Cuck behaviour, ngl chief.
  
  Or, it might be because some communities silence those who use certain words, regardless of context, and this person is trying to avoid that...
- So brave
- i’m not against you reclaiming slurs!, if that language is accepted in your communities and you aren’t using it to do value judgments or insult, this is totally slay and acceptable 🙂
  
  Of course I wouldnt say it if it made a neurodivergant person uncomfortable. Also I say it in a ironic sence to describe how people often treat me and other Autistic people as disabled.

Acoustic?
- Maybe you dont hear this in your circles but in my (younger) cohort it is ALL OVER THE PLACE and has been used against me in a derogatory manner
  
  I feel like the same people who use "acoustic" also use "regarded"
  
  definitely a generational thing
  
  Idk, I think it's gone out of fashion atp, but it was super annoying.
- They just can't catch a break trying to make this meme work, huh
- IDK, but I saw that being used within autistic communities first. At least for a while, which would explain this meme.
  
  Yeah, it was sadly a very quick development/devolvement from “cutesy term used by the ASD community” to “swap-in for the r-slur used by 99% of gen z internet.” something like a matter of months.
- https://knowyourmeme.com/editorials/guides/what-is-the-meaning-of-the-slang-term-acoustic-the-algospeak-word-and-its-memes-explained also ccing @Nutteman@lemmy.world

One of these things is not like the others.
- I can see the argument how there could have been an attempt to reclaim it, much like the n-slur, f-slur, or queer. Not sure if there was actually an attempt or not to reclaim, just to be clear.
  
  The difference is that Something like Retarded is used by someone else, someone who isn't like that person. It was a clinical term used by clinical people who would never know and could never know the feeling. That is to say it wasn't great to begin with. People who were "retarded" weren't embracing that for what they were, it was imposed upon them by medical professionals who don't really understand them as people (many were studying them like specimens). It was primed for derogatory use.
  Neurodivergent on the other hand is a term embraced by the community, it's used as a self-identifier. It doesn't have the same oppressive connotations the others did. To turn it into a slur would be like turning transgender into a slur. It won't work because the group identifies as that, and will keep using it.

Is it no longer alright for me to be retarded anymore?

Ian Dury had it right in 1981
https://youtu.be/UKnBgJG9A8E
- okay lets FUCKING go i dont know why your comment took so long to show up for me but this rocks! 🔥
  i love music that does this reclaiming. very cool and and a pretty effective middle finger to the would-be treadmillers. here’s another one that i love: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cdNn_duX4bE

huh? "special needs" has survived noticably better and "neurodivergent" is at this point on about the same level as calling yourself "INTP" or whatever, i don't think the cycle is gonna continue.
hell i'd say even just the practice of using diagnoses as insults is starting to die out, people are realizing that it's shitty.

57 comments