8mo ago

A ton of job postings might actually be fake

qz.com A ton of job postings might actually be fake

A new survey found that almost 40% of companies posted a fake job listing this year — and 85% of those companies interviewed candidates for fake jobs

A new survey found that almost 40% of companies posted a fake job listing this year — and 85% of those companies interviewed candidates for fake jobs

…

Companies said they are posting fake jobs for a laundry list of reasons, including to deceive their own employees.

More than 60% of those surveyed said they posted fake jobs “to make employees believe their workload would be alleviated by new workers.”

Sixty-two percent of companies said another reason for the shady practice is to “have employees feel replaceable.”

Two-thirds of companies cited a desire to “appear the company is open to external talent” and 59% said it was an effort to “collect resumes and keep them on file for a later date.”

What’s even more concerning about the results: 85% of companies engaging in the practice said they interviewed candidates for the fake jobs.

A Boring Dystopia @lemmy.world

lawrence @lemmy.world

8mo ago

A new survey found that almost 40% of companies posted a fake job listing this year (2024)

qz.com /companies-posting-fake-job-listings-resume-builder-1851556777

222 21

You're viewing a single thread.

49 comments

I'd be very interested to know what the wording was in their survey of 600 "HR managers". Because I find it hard to believe that companies would file job posts that they never intend to fill -- and then admit it in a survey. I find it more likely the Internet is trolling them
On the other hand, I would expect companies to put up job posts that they have every intention to fill if the right candidate comes along, but structure the job requiremrnts so that precisely 10 people in the entire country are fully qualified for the well-compensated position. And then complain that they can't fill the position while collecting everyone's resumes and getting back to a few of them saying "That position is no longer open, would you consider this one at half the salary?"
- I don't find it that hard to believe, they're responding anonymously so they know it won't hurt their specific company's image, and the general message of "there's a lot of untrustworthy bullshit out there for job seekers (so if we do make an offer you better take it because your fallback plan might be a mirage) (and, y'know what, just in general - we have all the power here and we are going to lie to you and not feel bad about it because thats normal for us, so don't even think about complaining to anyone about it)" is one that serves all their interests
  I think your "On the other hand etc." is a pretty accurate guess at specifically how they do this, tho
  
  I don't find it that hard to believe, they're responding anonymously
  If they're responding anonymously on the Internet, they could be anyone. We have no way of knowing whether they really are hiring managers, or whether the site doing this "poll" made it up for clicks. I'm skeptical of everything I read on the Internet, even if it comes to a conclusion I agree with.
  
  Usually for a poll like this, they would make invitations to targeted respondents and provide them with secure anonymous access when they agree.
  
  It does not provide the details, but I highly doubt the polling was done anonymously online. You're right, that would be completely useless.
  However, polling done offline also needs to be anonymized, even though it is offline and the pollster knows the identities of the participants, simply to protect them from repercussions.
- Pretty sure signing over your soul is a requirement for HR positions. They do blatantly illegal things all the time and do not care. So yes, they will happily tell the truth in an anonymous survey.
- They've grown day and happy working their post-covid skeleton crews to the bone.
  Why would they want to alleviate that by paying for additional salaries?
  
  They is not a monolith.
- If they're just doing it because their boss tells them to, why wouldn't they admit to it in an anonymous survey?

49 comments