You're viewing a single thread.
Did y'all forget that Frodo went to the Undying Lands? He only visits for work.
Edit: it seems I've forgotten... he'd still age in the Undying Lands.
This confirms he is a Dark Lord then, and must have purposefully sought to infiltrate Valinor. I don't dare to guess his intentions...
Doesn't he go to Valinor to die though? He doesn't live forever just because he was a ringbearer, he went for some healing and respite before moving on to the Doom of Hobbits. I always thought the Quest and the Wound caused him to 'die' young, he never healed, he left for Valinor, had a nice peaceful nap in Elvenlands, and died happy.
and died
Oh. Not really the "undying lands" then, is it?
It is for Elves, not Hobbits or Men, which is why it was such a big deal he even got invited to chill.
It is for Elves
Aren't elves already immortal?