Stop Treating Phone Numbers As A Digital ID
Stop Treating Phone Numbers As A Digital ID
notthesolution.substack.com Stop Treating Phone Numbers As A Digital ID
Are internet security and internet privacy incompatible goals?
You're viewing a single thread.
170 comments
-
To the same audience: quit selling my fucking phone number!
I ditched a phone number I had for 10+ years because it was leaked everywhere. Only a few short months after updating my number with the DMV and a handful of other government agencies I started receiving scam calls/messages again.
At some point we need to adopt some fucking privacy laws. This is absolutely bonkers—is no one else fed up??
Edit: I already know how to silence unknown callers. What I want is to not have the problem in the first place, ideally by 1) having companies not sell personal data to third parties and 2) being able to block spoofed (non-encrypted) caller ID.
-
Oh everyone is fed up but we just elected a guy and government who is sure to make it all way way way worse.
He just helped put the nail in the coffin of the lie that crypto is for anything but scams, don't worry, it's gonna get real bad before it gets any better.
-
In South Africa, where I live, everyone is assigned an ID Number at Birth. You need an ID number, thumbprint scan AND proof of address to get issued a SIM card number due to a law introduced called RICA. It was meant to help fight crime. Worried that the government could listen in to calls or read their SMSs, the criminals just switched to WhatsApp, which also happened to become cheaper than SMSs and gained popularity in this time.
The cops never seemed to crack WhatsApp. The only drug busts that happen are when an open secret becomes laughably too open and when they harass every person arriving from South America at O.R. Tambo international airport just to catch the decoy mules carrying 12g of cocaine (total). Every dealer I ever organised with was over WhatsApp.
So now, woopsi, RICA stopped nothing and just became a liability. That treasure trove of fragile data made its way to scammers and spammers. A total net negative.
I'd encourage everyone else in other countries to apply major pushback to any government proposals in this direction.
-
Do people still believe that drug trade is ran by criminals?
I am pretty sure in every country, it is controlled either police or the spooks.
I am done pretending otherwise. Criminals are just useful idiots, the real thugs are the police and security apparatus
-
[citation needed]
-
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIA_involvement_in_Contra_cocaine_trafficking
This is just one example;)
-
there are MANY MANY examples don't be a lazy pelican with your beak open. go look
-
The person who makes a claim has to back it up
-
stay ignorant and dangerous friend
-
-
-
-
-
-
Did we? My government leader hasn't changed nor have we had an election lately
-
There's a subset of Americans who are rather like ostriches: heads so deeply buried in the sand that they forget anything exists outside their immediate surroundings. Reminding them that the rest of the world is out there rarely has any positive results, however.
-
If they could read they would be upset by that.
-
-
-
"Bitcoin, it just seems like a scam," Mr Trump said. "I don't like it because it's another currency competing against the dollar."
— Donald Trump
Of course, Trump Coin made just for him is fine. And any security who bribes him. Oh wait now none of them are securities; Gary Gensler was our last line of defense.
[Edit: got it backwards]
-
-
I'm pretty sure a lot of scam calls use machines that call every possible phone number within an area code and see who answers. There is no way to avoid it.
-
this right here. I stopped getting scam calls years ago, I stopped answering and they just eventually stopped calling. If you don't interact with the call (interact being ignore it or mute it NOT reject it) and it just goes to voicemail, they seem to eventually stop
-
Lucky you. I've been letting calls from any number I don't recognize go to voicemail for years and nothing ever seems to change.
-
Setup a whitelist, I think it's native on iPhone and there are multiple Android apps. Only calls from your contact list will ring through. My voicemail is, "You're getting this because you're not on my contact list, send a text and I'll get back to you."
-
I just block and report as spam any spam text messages I get and any calls that get marked as scam likely. It was terrible before the election because I live in a swing county in a swing state and I think everyone was just mass spamming every number in the area code, but since then I haven’t really gotten much, maybe one errant text every 2 or 3 weeks. Which is much better than it was last spring and summer when the amount started picking up for me.
-
-
If you're job hunting, or work in specific fields this may not be a reasonable thing to do and that's at least part of the problem.
-
This would deem troublesome yea, being said I firmly believe in separating work and home. I wouldn't be willing to use a personal number for work related activities, at least not public related activities. Being said, I have no good solution for that, at least you are being paid for the scam call I guess.
-
Job hunting is what I meant. And you pretty much have to use your personal phone for that. I haven't ever had a company phone. Doubt they'd give it to techs.
-
-
-
-
-
lists sourced from drivers licenses and motor vehicle registration records are literally sold by some states.
-
Source?
-
wisconsin literally has an opt-out/opt-in (based on your current status) box on vehicle registration renewal forms, for one.
-
-
Yep, wish I’d known that a couple years ago.
-
-
quit
sellingdemanding my fucking phone number!FTFY
-
Australia has a "do not call register". It seems to mostly work, but telcos are having trouble with calls originating from outside the network with spoofed caller ID. We still get spam/scam calls from India among other places.
Even if they're not calling you directly, they are still using your phone number to link you to things and create a shadow profile behind the scenes.
-
So does the US, though you need to re-register every so often. It works pretty well, but it's not advertised very well.
-
-
Don't worry, here in Europe we are full of privacy laws but I still receive tents of spam calls per day. Usually from non UE countries faking the number with my country numbers.
-
Anything with a London 020 number is guaranteed to be a man with an Indian accent pretending to be from British Telecom.
-
-
I set my phone to decline calls from unknown callers years ago.
These calls are already illegal. I used to report them to the FTC but I never heard anything back so I have no idea what happens, but I presume nothing. If I had the time to take them, and if they spoke English, I would record them with the Cube ACR app (which no longer works) and convince them to incriminate themselves. Ask their name, company, location, time/date, whether they ran my number through the DNC registry.
-
At some point we need to adopt some fucking privacy laws.
Yeah we absolutely had to ban TilTok because of privacy concerns but the idea of creating a law to protect our privacy is ridiculous beyond all reasoning. The stupidity of the United States government is absolute.
-
Agreed, but I’m not addressing TikTok specifically but rather policies similar to GDPR.
-
-
At some point we need to adopt some fucking privacy laws. This is absolutely bonkers—is no one else fed up??
Look at you, trying to use the government to solve every day problems that face pretty much all of us.
Don't you know we only focus on gridlock issues to distract us from real issues now?
-
I do, unfortunately.
-
-
I have an app called Silence that lets me block calls from numbets not in my addreasbook. Highly recommended
https://github.com/x13a/Silence
Reminder: Dont blindly trust random internet sources!
-
That’s not the problem I’m referring to; this is already built-in to iOS (and I hope Android).
-
-
I'm confused of how this keeps happening to people.
Like I use my phone on most sites that allow it and I've never had spam/scam calls really, but I've also explicitly unchecked the marketing boxes that appear on the signup so maybe that it.
The last instance that actually happened to me was with entering my university a few years ago for my BS degree. They 1000% sold my contact information as some part of the deans/honors list process. I reached out to them and stopped that so fast.
-
170 comments